In P.S. I Love You, Ted spots Jeanette during a train ride, but she exits the train before he can talk to her. However, the next day, he sees Jeanette outside the university where he teaches, where she tells him that she looked him up from the details she remembered about him and that if the fire alarm hadn't gone off, she wouldn't have found him. The gang thinks that Jeanette is a stalker but Ted disagrees. He later asks her if she was the one who pulled the fire alarm, and she says she was. However, Marshall and Lily notice that there isn't a fire alarm in the university, meaning that Jeanette started a fire to sound an alarm, which turned out to be true. However, Ted is charmed by these things. Later, at his apartment, Ted tells Jeanette that if she hadn't been reading the same book as