The Cupid Judge first appears in the Court of Love to hold trial against Coop Halliwell's most recent actions, namely his involvement in retrieving Benjamin Turner's soul and affairs of the Charmed Ones' battles. Deeming that he needed to be away from his family to focus on his job, the Judge sentenced him separation from his wife and children, only allowing them to unite on their wedding anniversaries. The Judge is among the Tribunal members who are massacred when Prue arrives to collect Ben, Kyra, Tyler Michaels, and Coop.