| rdfs:comment | - [[File:Oasis.png|thumb|right|261px|New image]] Image was not used in the mainspace Reason: Centered, no camel in the front, no fog in the background, better colors(previous one was grey-ish)
* Support - As nom. left:9px;top:4px;">Jleft:25px;top:3px;">Oright:1px;bottom:4px;">Eleft:2px;bottom:5px;">Yright:4px;top:2px;">Tright:20px;bottom:7px;">Jright:5px;top:6px;">Eright:2px;bottom:3px;">5right:10px;bottom:5px;">0left:6px; top:6px;">Tleft:6px;top:4px;">Aleft:8px;top:3px;">Lright:4px;bottom:2px;">K pull my finger 01:55, August 7, 2010 (UTC)
* Oppose - The previous image followed the rule of thirds (off center is good). The camel gives it a much better sense of place. Riblet15 03:42, August 7, 2010 (UTC) Commment - The new image also got some rule of thirds things.[1] And i know the
|
| abstract | - [[File:Oasis.png|thumb|right|261px|New image]] Image was not used in the mainspace Reason: Centered, no camel in the front, no fog in the background, better colors(previous one was grey-ish)
* Support - As nom. left:9px;top:4px;">Jleft:25px;top:3px;">Oright:1px;bottom:4px;">Eleft:2px;bottom:5px;">Yright:4px;top:2px;">Tright:20px;bottom:7px;">Jright:5px;top:6px;">Eright:2px;bottom:3px;">5right:10px;bottom:5px;">0left:6px; top:6px;">Tleft:6px;top:4px;">Aleft:8px;top:3px;">Lright:4px;bottom:2px;">K pull my finger 01:55, August 7, 2010 (UTC)
* Oppose - The previous image followed the rule of thirds (off center is good). The camel gives it a much better sense of place. Riblet15 03:42, August 7, 2010 (UTC) Commment - The new image also got some rule of thirds things.[1] And i know the thirds aren't exact thirds, but they aren't at the current image either[2] left:9px;top:4px;">Jleft:25px;top:3px;">Oright:1px;bottom:4px;">Eleft:2px;bottom:5px;">Yright:4px;top:2px;">Tright:20px;bottom:7px;">Jright:5px;top:6px;">Eright:2px;bottom:3px;">5right:10px;bottom:5px;">0left:6px; top:6px;">Tleft:6px;top:4px;">Aleft:8px;top:3px;">Lright:4px;bottom:2px;">K pull my finger 12:39, August 7, 2010 (UTC) You really don't need to respond to every single thing I say, but more accurate lines are [3] and [4]. The general rule of thirds is to try and keep the subject (in the original, the camel/things off to the left, in the new one...uh, the center lake?) outside of the center box, not necessarily along the lines. Riblet15 18:26, August 7, 2010 (UTC)
* Oppose - The new image is quite good, but it has some cut-off things to the right, which the original one doesn't have. Also....... CAMELS FTW! Fswe1 06:03, August 7, 2010 (UTC)
* Neutral - They are both terrible. bad_fetustalk 08:01, August 7, 2010 (UTC)
* Oppose - Per all. 222 talk 08:24, August 7, 2010 (UTC)
* Support - Per nom. --Coolnesse 11:28, August 7, 2010 (UTC)
* Oppose - per Fswe and Riblet User:LordDarkPhantom/Signature 13:46, August 7, 2010 (UTC) Woohoo, I'm "perred"! File:XD.gif Fswe1 13:50, August 7, 2010 (UTC)
* Comment Did you read the thing i answered below riblet's post? and to Fswe1: gefeliciteerd File:Smile.gif. left:9px;top:4px;">Jleft:25px;top:3px;">Oright:1px;bottom:4px;">Eleft:2px;bottom:5px;">Yright:4px;top:2px;">Tright:20px;bottom:7px;">Jright:5px;top:6px;">Eright:2px;bottom:3px;">5right:10px;bottom:5px;">0left:6px; top:6px;">Tleft:6px;top:4px;">Aleft:8px;top:3px;">Lright:4px;bottom:2px;">K pull my finger 14:59, August 7, 2010 (UTC) Bedankt, lol. Fswe1 15:20, August 7, 2010 (UTC)
* Oppose - Per Riblet. 17:57, August 7, 2010 (UTC)
* Oppose - Per Fswe. File:Ranged-icon.png Zap0i TalkFile:Rune scimitar.png 20:58, August 7, 2010 (UTC)
* Oppose - Per Riblet File:Farming cape (t).png Lil cloud 9 Talk 23:45, August 7, 2010 (UTC)
* Support - The new one looks nice without the white sky in the background. 03:26, August 9, 2010 (UTC)
* Closed - Nomination for replacement is unsuccessful. C.ChiamTalk 13:04, August 14, 2010 (UTC)
|
