| Property | Value |
|---|
| rdfs:label | - Articles for deletion/Dunes Review
|
| rdfs:comment | - This article is about a literary magazine, Dunes Review (DR for short) from North Michigan. It has currently 16 references. I will go through each one of them, the numbers refer to the version at the moment of filing this AFD. 1/ Short radio item on a local station. DR is mentioned in-passing. 2/ In-passing mention of the magazine on poets.org. 3/ Short item on a poet on the website of the Michigan State University Libraries, mentioning that she has published in DR. 4/ Short biographical item on a poet including DR in a list of magazines where this person has published. 5/ A few lines in a local newspaper (Traverse City Record-Eagle) on a "Dunes Review launch party". 6/ Another item in another local newspaper, the Grand Traverse Insider. I cannot locate this online, but given its title, I
|
| dbkwik:speedydeletion/property/wikiPageUsesTemplate | |
| abstract | - This article is about a literary magazine, Dunes Review (DR for short) from North Michigan. It has currently 16 references. I will go through each one of them, the numbers refer to the version at the moment of filing this AFD. 1/ Short radio item on a local station. DR is mentioned in-passing. 2/ In-passing mention of the magazine on poets.org. 3/ Short item on a poet on the website of the Michigan State University Libraries, mentioning that she has published in DR. 4/ Short biographical item on a poet including DR in a list of magazines where this person has published. 5/ A few lines in a local newspaper (Traverse City Record-Eagle) on a "Dunes Review launch party". 6/ Another item in another local newspaper, the Grand Traverse Insider. I cannot locate this online, but given its title, I don't think this provides in-depth coverage of DR. 7/ WorldCat entry for the magazine. WorldCat covers anything that has an ISSN or ISBN, so inclusion in it does not constitute any evidence of notability. WorldCat indicates that not a single library in Michigan (or even the whole of the United States) holds this journal. 8/ An item in the Glen Arbor Sun, a local freely-distributed magazine appearing 10 times per year, written by on of DR's editors (Holly Spaulding). 9/ DR itself. 10/ DR itself. 11/ Website of one of the sponsoring organisations. 12/ Website of the other sponsoring organization. 13/ Short item on a poet including DR in a list of magazines where this person has published. 14/ Short item on a poet who has published in DR, mentioning that this person won a National Endowment for the Arts grant. 15/ Another brief item in the Record Eagle on a "Dunes Review launch party". 16/ Another item in the Glen Arbor Sun. From the title and the snippet cited in the article, it does not appear to provide in-depth coverage of DR. Summarizing the above: there are no sources that provide any in depth-coverage of the magazine (and certainly none that would be independent of it) or even anythign more than an in-passing mention of it. There is no indication that WP:GNG (or any other guideline that might apply) has been met. In the absence of reliable sources establishing notability: Delete. Note: the explanation for this unusually long and detailed nomination can be found on the talk page (and its history) of this article. Guillaume2303 (talk) 15:29, 13 July 2012 (UTC)
|
